Evaluation of the Level of Urban Social Resilience to Earthquakes Using a Good Urban Governance Approach

Document Type : Case Study


1 Department of Architecture, Faculty of Art and Urban Planning, Islamic Azad University, Tehran-North Branch, Tehran, Iran

2 Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, Islamic Azad University, Qazvin Branch, Qazvin, Iran


Resilience is one of the most important factors to achieve sustainable management and good urban governance and it is a way towards the improvement of communities building upon their capacities. Therefore, in present research social resilience of Zanjan city to earthquakes was evaluated using a descriptive-analytical method. The present study employed a database (Geographical Information System (GIS), an analytical-spatial model (social resilience evaluation model) and a decision-making model (Quantified  Strategic  Planning  Matrix  (QSPM)).  Factors  that  contribute  to  the  level  of  social  resilience studied in the present research consisted of four criteria and twenty-eight sub-criteria. They were weighted based on their importance using an analytic hierarchical process (AHP); then GIS was used to address the level of social resilience of Zanjan city to earthquakes and finally vulnerable areas and neighborhoods were identified. Findings suggest that about 40% of Zanjan city area is of a low resilience to earthquakes and the most vulnerable areas include the old texture of such neighborhoods as Islam Abad and Kooye Farhang in District 3, Bisim in District 5 and such neighborhoods as Sabzeh Meidan and Davoud Qoli road located in Districts 1 and 2. In the next step, QSPM was used for decision making and selection of optimal strategies in order to prioritize strategies to implement in areas with high vulnerability and low social resilience.


Abdollahi, M., (2011). Municipality as a Social Institution (Strategies for Converting Municipality from a Service Organization to a Social Institution), Tehran, Tehran Municipality. Department of Social and Cultural Affairs.
Ainuddin, S., & Routray, J. K. (2012). Community resilience framework for an earthquake-prone area in Baluchistan. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2, 25-36. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijdrr.2012.07.003
Alexander, D. E., (2013). Resilience and disaster risk reduction: an etymological journey. n Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci. Discuss.: 17 April 2013.
Allan, P., & Bryant, M., (2012). Resilience as a framework for urbanism and recovery.
Allen, C. R., Birge, H. E., Bartelt-Hunt, S., Bevans, R. A., Burnett, J. L., Cosens, B. A. Uden, D. R., (2016). Avoiding decline: Fostering resilience and sustainability in midsize cities. Sustainability (Switzerland), 8(9). doi: 10.3390/su8090844.
Armanshahr Consulting Engineers., (2006), Detailed Plan of Zanjan City, Zanjan.
Barak Pour, N., (2006). Urban Governance and Administrative System of Cities in Iran", Urban Planning and Management Conference.
Barak Pour. N.; Asadi, I., (2011).Urban management and Governance, Tehran University of Art Press.
Brikmann, J., (2005). Research Brief, Danger Need Not Spell Disaster, but how vulnerable are we?” United     Nations University. Institute of Environment and Human Security. Available:http://online.Northumbria.ac.uk/geography_research/radix/resources/Brikmann_Research_v2. Pdf.
Cangelosi, E., (2015). Reshaping spaces and relations: Urban gardening in a time of crisis. Partecipazione e Conflitto, 8(2), 392-416. doi: 10.1285/i20356609v8i2p392.
Carpenter, A., (2015). Resilience in the social and physical realms: Lessons from the Gulf Coast. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 14, 290-301. doi:  http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijdrr.2014.09.003
Chardon, A., ( 2006). A Geographic Approach of the Global Vulnerability in Urban Areas: Case of Manizales, Colombian Andes. Geojournal. 49: 197-212.
Cutter, S.L, Boruff, B. J and Shirley, W. L., (2003), “Social Vulnerability to Environmental Hazards”, Social Science Quarterly 84 (2): 242- 261.
Cutter, S.L, and Emrich, C.T., (2006). Moral Hazard, Social Catastrophe: The Changing Face of Vulnerability along the Hurricane Coasts”, the Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 604: 102- 112
Cutter, S.L., (2006). The Geography of Social Vulnerability: Race, Class, and Catastrophe”, understanding Katrina: perspectives from the social and science. Available at: HTTP:// understanding Katrina. Ssrc. Org/ Cutter/ pdf.
Dwyer, A., Zoppou, C., Nielsen, O., Day, S. & Roberts, S., (2004). Quantifying Social Vulnerability: A methodology for identifying those at risk to natural hazards”, GeoCat No. 61168, Geoscience Australia.
Ebert, A.; Kerle, N.;  Stein, A., (2008). Urban Social Vulnerability Assessment with Physical Proxies and Spatial Metrics Derived from Air- and Spaceborne Imagery and GIS Data, Journal of Nathazards, 48:2, 275-294.
Farzad Behtash, M. R.; Pir Babaei, M.; Taqi, M., Key Nejad, M.; Babaei., (2012), Clarification of Dimensions and Components of Islamic Urban Resilience, Period 3, No. 9: 114.
Habibi, et al., (2008), Determining Structural Factors Influencing Vulnerability of Old Texture of Zanjan City Using Fuzzy Logic and GIS, Journal of Fine Arts, No. 22, pp. 27-36.
Habibi, K.; Sar Kargar Ardakani, A., (2009). Urban Vulnerability and GIS, a dissertation in partial fulfillment of the requirements for Masters' degree, The Imam Hossein Comprehensive University, Payambare Akram (PBUH) School and Institute, Tehran.
Holling, C. S., (1996). Engineering resilience versus ecological resilience. Washington: Engineering within ecological constraints. National Academy.
Gunderson, L., (2009). Comparing Ecological and Human Community Resilience. CARRI Research Report 5. Oak Ridge: Community and Regional Resilience Institute. [online] http://www.resilientus.org/library/Final_Gunderson_11209_123177474.pdf.
Kazemi, D., (2015), Formulation of a Conceptual Framework to Assess Components Influencing Urban Resilience to Earthquake Crisis, Case Study of Tehran City", Ph.D. dissertation of Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch.
Klein, J. & Dawar, N., (2004)." Corporate social responsibility and consumers’ attributions of brand evaluations in product-harm crisis." International Journal of Marketing, 21, 203-217.
Maleki, A., (2007), Earthquake Hazard Zoning and Prioritization of Housing Rehabilitation in Kordestan Province, Quarterly of Geographical Research, University of Tehran, No. 59.
Mayunga, J.S., (2007). Understanding and Applying the Concept of Community Disaster Endurance: A capital-based approach a draft working paper prepared for the summer academy for social vulnerability and endurance building, 22-28, July 2007, Munich, p.1-4.
Mcloughlin, B., (1973), Control and Urban Planning, London: Faber and Faber.
Mileti, D.S., (1999). Disasters by design: a reassessment of natural hazards in the United States. Natural hazards and disasters. Joseph Henry Press. Washington. DC.
Naghshe Mohit Consulting Engineers., (2013). Urban Development (Master) Plan of Zanjan City, Zanjan.
Nakabayashi, I. (1994). Urban Planning Based on Disaster Assessment. In Disaster Management in Metropolitan Areas for the 21st Century, Proceedings of the IDNDR. Aichi/ Nagoya International Conference, Nagoya, Japan: 225-239.
Pimm, S. L., (1984). The complexity and stability of ecosystems.
Rafieian, M.; Rezaei, M.R.; Asgari, Ali.; Parhizkar, A.; Shayan, S., (2011). Conceptual Clarification of Resilience and Development of Its Indicators in Community-Based Disaster Management (CBDM), Quarterly of Humanities Teacher, No. 74, Winter.
Rafieian, M.; Motahhari, Z., (2012). Designing a Model to Study Community-Based Disaster Management (Case Study of Volunteers of Neighborhood Emergency Response Plan), Quarterly of Crisis Management, No. 1, Spring and Summer, pp. 5-12. 
Rezaei. M. R., (2010). Clarifying Resilience of Urban Communities to Mitigate Impact of Natural Disasters (Earthquake), Case Study of Tehran Metropolis, Ph.D. dissertation in Geography and Urban Management, Tarbiat Modares University. 
Rezaei, M.R.; Rafieian, M.; Hosseini, M., (2015). Evaluation of the Extent of Physical Resilience of Urban Communities to Earthquakes, Case Study of Tehran Neighborhoods. Human Geography Research, Period 47, No 4.
Salman Moqaddam, M.; Kavian, F., (2014). Role of Land Use Planning in Improvement of Resilience of Urban Community to Earthquake Using GIS, Geographical Studies of Arid Regions, 5th Year, No 17.
Schuetze, T., & Chelleri, L., (2013). Integrating decentralized rainwater management in urban planning and design: Flood resilient and sustainable water management using the example of coastal cities in The Netherlands and Taiwan. Water (Switzerland), 5(2), 593-616. doi: 10.3390/w5020593.
Statistical Center of Iran., (2006), General Censuses of Population and Housing, Zanjan Province. Zanjan.
Studies of Land Use Planning Project of Zanjan Province., (2010), 9th Vol: Analysis of Situation and Structure, Zanjan City, Zanjan.  
Timmermans, H., (2007). If we Develop It- They Will Not Use It: On The Dissemination of Spatial Decision Support System in Urban Planning. a paper presented to the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy Program Planning Support Systems Seminar. Cambridge. MA.
Ziari, Y.A., (2015). Decision Making Models and Techniques in Urban Planning with an Emphasis on Urban Land Use Planning", Islamic Azad University. Central Tehran Branch, 1-0942-10-964-9782.
Ziari, Y. A.; Ebadollah Zadeh Maleki, B., (2017). Evaluation of the Extent of Social Resilience to Earthquake Crisis, Case Study of District 1 of Tehran", Fourth International Conference on Recent Innovations in Architecture. Urban Development and Civil Engineering.
Ziari, Y.A.; Ebadollah Zadeh Maleki, B.; Behzadpoor, E., (2017). Evaluation of the Extent of Physical Resilience to Earthquake Hazards with an Approach to Achieve Sustainable Management (Case Study of District 1 of Tehran. Quarterly of A New Attitude to Human Geography, 10th Year, No. 2, Spring 2018.